Swell Investing Review: A Deep Dive into Socially Responsible Investing

Susan Kelly Updated on Oct 17, 2023

In the ever-evolving financial technology landscape, Swell Investing once stood as a shining example of a platform catering to socially responsible investors. With its innovative approach, thematic portfolios, and commitment to ethical investments, Swell captured the attention of those looking to impact the world while growing their wealth positively.

However, as of August 2019, Swell Investing has ceased its operations. In this Swell Investing review, we will explore the pros and cons of investing in Swell, investigate the reasons behind its closure, and offer alternatives for socially responsible investing.

Introduction to Swell Investing

Swell Investing was a unique robo-advisory platform that allows investors to tailor their profiles to their values. Founded in 2017, it provided a platform for investors who wanted to support socially responsible causes and companies while seeking financial returns. Here's a breakdown of what Swell Investing offered:

Let’s explore the main features and benefits of Swell investments:

Thematic Portfolios

Swell Investing stood out in the world of robo-advisors by offering a diverse array of thematic portfolios. Each portfolio was meticulously curated to address social or environmental issues, aligning investments with investors' values.

This innovative feature allowed users to put their money to work in causes they genuinely cared about, ranging from clean energy initiatives to gender diversity and green technology. Swell's thematic portfolios weren't just about financial returns; they empowered investors to drive positive change in the world through their investments.

Impact Insights

Swell's commitment to transparency and impact reporting was a game-changer in socially responsible investing. The platform went beyond financial metrics, providing users with invaluable insights into the real-world effects of their swell investments. Investors could track and visualize the positive changes their money was making, whether contributing to carbon reduction efforts or enhancing clean water access. This feature allowed investors to see the tangible outcomes of their ethical investment choices, fostering a deeper connection between their financial goals and their desire to create a better world.

Low Minimum Balance

Accessibility has always been a critical factor in the world of investing. Swell recognized this and addressed it by setting a low minimum investment requirement. This lowered the barrier to entry for socially responsible investing, welcoming a more diverse range of investors into the fold. Even those with modest capital could participate, allowing them to make a difference without needing substantial resources.

No-Commission Policy

Swell's no-commission policy was fresh air in a world where fees can eat into investors' returns. By not charging any commissions, the platform ensured that investors got to keep more of their hard-earned money. This fee structure made Swell an attractive choice, particularly for cost-conscious investors keen on maximizing their returns while still adhering to their values.

Pros and Cons of Swell Investing

Swell Investing once shone as a guiding star in a financial landscape where conscience meets capitalism. With its pioneering approach to socially responsible investing, it beckoned to those seeking both financial returns and a positive impact on society.

Pros

Let's dive into the pros:

Socially Responsible Investing

Swell's thematic portfolios allowed investors to contribute to causes they were passionate about, making it a unique platform for robo-advisors. Investors could align their investments with their values without sacrificing potential returns.

Impact Insights

Swell's focus on impact reporting provided transparency and allowed investors to see the real-world effects of their investments.

Low Minimum Balance

The low minimum investment requirement made Swell available to various investors, including those just starting their investment journey.

No-Commission Policy

Swell's fee structure was investor-friendly, ensuring investors retained more returns.

Cons

These are the cons:

Limited Investment Options

Swell's emphasis on socially responsible investing meant it had a limited range of investment options compared to some traditional robo-advisors.

Closure

The most significant drawback is the closure of Swell Investing in August 2019, leaving existing investors searching for alternatives.

Reasons for Swell Investing's Closure

The closure of Swell Investing came as a surprise to many investors who had embraced its socially responsible investment approach. The following factors are believed to have contributed to this decision:

  • Swell Investing operated in a highly competitive market, and the demand for socially responsible investing was growing but still relatively niche. The intense competition may have posed challenges for scaling the business.
  • Growing a robo-advisory platform like Swell required substantial resources. Achieving scalability while maintaining the quality of thematic portfolios and impact reporting might have been a formidable task.
  • While Swell catered to a socially conscious audience, it may have struggled to achieve sustainable profitability due to its no-commission policy and focus on ethical investments.

Alternatives for Socially Responsible Investing

Despite the closure of Swell Investing, the appetite for socially responsible investing remains strong. Several alternatives offer a similar ethos and a range of features to cater to investors seeking to make a positive impact:

Wealthsimple

Wealthsimple offers a socially responsible investing portfolio that aligns with investors' values. It provides a user-friendly platform with a low minimum balance requirement.

M1 Finance

M1 Finance allows investors to customize their portfolios and include socially responsible ETFs. The platform offers fractional shares and a robust investment automation feature.

Betterment

Betterment's SRI portfolio includes a mix of ETFs that adhere to socially responsible criteria. It offers goal-based investing and tax optimization features.

Ellevest

Ellevest focuses on serving women investors and offers customized portfolios with a gender lens. It offers a plethora of educational resources to empower investors.

Motif Investing

Motif Investing enables investors to create and invest in customized thematic portfolios, including socially responsible themes. It offers a unique approach to portfolio construction.

COIN

COIN is a platform dedicated to impact investing, allowing users to invest in companies addressing global challenges. It provides a straightforward and user-friendly interface for impact-focused investors.

Wrapping Up!

Swell Investing was a pioneering platform that aimed to make a mark through socially appropriate investing. While it had its strengths and limitations, its closure marked a turning point in ethical investing. Investors now have a variety of alternatives to choose from, each with its unique approach to socially responsible investing.

As the financial technology landscape evolves, investors must stay informed and select the platform that best aligns with their values and financial goals.